How links are checked
Every link, whether a member shares it or the site gathers it from a trusted news source, goes through the same checks before anyone sees it.
First, the quick checks
- The link works and is new. We open the page once. If it fails, needs a login, or was shared here in the last 90 days, it stops here. A repeat link adds your vote to the existing story instead.
- Sources we do not accept are declined at once.
Then our AI reader
An AI reader goes through the page against five more checks:
- On topic. It is about God, faith, prayer, the Church, charity, religious traditions, or research that bears on the spiritual life.
- Trustworthy source. A known publisher, a church or religious body, a university, a reputable charity, or a writer with a clear name.
- Charitable in tone. It reports or argues fairly, even when critical.
- Honest headline. The title says what the article says.
- Fits the guidelines. Nothing presents as Catholic something contrary to Catholic teaching, and nothing shows nudity or sexual content.
It also writes the short brief you see under the title, picks the topic, and judges how much the story matters, which helps order the front page while the site is young.
When a person steps in
The AI reader decides clear cases. When it is unsure, the link is held for a steward, a person who reads it and decides. A steward also checks a random sample of the AI's decisions every week, and corrects the rules where it got things wrong.
The AI reader is not a theological authority. Whenever it is genuinely unsure about a question of doctrine or modesty, a person decides.
Appeals
If your link is declined, the decline message has a link to ask a steward for a second look. You can appeal each decision once, and the steward's answer is final.
What we keep
We read the page only to check it. The page text is deleted once checking finishes. We keep a record of each decision and the reason for it, so decisions can be explained.